A Final Appeal: Problem Log

The First Amendment and To Kill a Mockingbird

By Shelagh A. Gallagher, Ph.D., Dana L. Plowden

Order Code: 7312
Class sets 10 or more paperback books: $7.00 each
Class set order code: 7312S

The Problem Log for the Final Appeal problem-based learning (PBL) unit is where students record their work. It contains activity sheets, formal assignments, and other pages that are essential to students as they progress through the unit.


A teacher has been fired for using To Kill a Mockingbird in her class. She sued the district and lost. Now she is appealing to a district court. In this PBL unit, students take on the role of members of the court of appeals who must decide the case.

Based on an actual court case, A Final Appeal instructs students in the nuances of the First Amendment. Framed around the concept of continuity, students learn how court decisions are made as they address the same questions facing real judges. What speech is protected, and what is not? What are the rights of employers and employees? What is the role of stare decicis, the rule that compels judges to follow precedent cases? Students also learn about the structure of the U.S. court system—and if there is time, they read To Kill a Mockingbird, too!

This unit is perfect for middle school or high school government courses, language arts courses, or interdisciplinary instruction.


Problem-Based Learning
A Final Appeal Problem-Based Learning Unit
11, 12, 13, 14, 15
5, 6, 7, 8, 9
Other Language Arts, History, Problem-Based Learning, Problem-Solving
Order Code